How Pfizer (PFE) Signaled A Difficult Year For Shareholders
Posted on: Jan 6th, 2009 | By Andrew Snyder | Filed under Stock Market Investing
Reading between the lines is key to successful stock market investing today, says Andrew Snyder. Pfizer’s (NYSE:PFE) announcement that it is looking to acquire rival companies in 2009 signals that organic growth will be hard to come by. And that’s bad news for shareholders. Andrew says savvy investors can bet against the company by short selling or buying put options.
This from Today’s Financial News:
If you want to make money in today’s market with its super-efficient flow of information, you need advanced insight. Remember, this is not your father’s buy-and-hold stock market.
Sure, crunching a few ratios and digging into a company’s balance sheet and income statement will give you a strong head start, but if you want to truly excel, you have to understand the psychological side of Wall Street.
For a perfect example, check out the headlines surrounding Pfizer (NYSE:PFE). The company went out of its way to tell reporters this morning that it is open to acquisitions of its rivals, big and small, if they will lead to revenue growth.
Well, duh. What company is not open to acquisitions if it will increase shareholder value?
There is much more to this story. The headlines are only an invitation to dig deeper.
No need for a crystal ball
Fortunately, you do not need an ultra-secret Wall Street decoder ring to figure out what is happening. All you need is an understanding of signaling theory.
The notion behind the influential theory is the idea of asymmetric information. There are unequal flows of knowledge in the investing world. In other words, a company’s executives and insiders know more about the company than even the most well-connected investor.
Signaling is a very important variable for dividend investors. A company’s willingness to expand or continues its dividend “signals” that the top brass has confidence in its future earnings potential.
But what is going on when a company’s CEO picks up the phone and tells the world it is willing to buy its rivals? Unfortunately, it is not a positive signal.
Pfizer’s performance over the past five years has been less than stellar. An investor that put $100,000 into the company in January of 2004 would have a position worth just $50,000 today (excluding dividends).
The company, and its Big Pharma kin, have had more than their share of troubles recently. Research and development costs are soaring, insurance companies are tightening the healthcare noose and generic competition is heating up. That means revenue growth is stagnant and margins are decreasing. It is not a recipe for shareholder profits.
Read between the lines
By telling the world his company needs a large acquisition, Pfizer’s CEO, Jeff Kindler, is signaling that 2009 will not look any different. The only way the mature company will grow is by purchasing the growth.
That means shareholders are going to take a hit and possibly a sizeable one, at least in the short-term. Smart investors will heed the warning of today’s signal and take appropriate action.
As I write, shares of Pfizer are closing in on the $19 mark, nearly 20% off their 10-year low reached in late November. The recent surge could be setting investors up for a drastic near-term reversal, especially if more merger news hits the press.
Basic investors should do their best to avoid a position in Pfizer. Investors with a bit more tolerance to speculation should take a look at a short position on the equity or some mid-term put options. As this story develops, Pfizer’s woes will only increase.
Keep an eye out for more news on the situation. Pfizer may be a bad choice, but the companies in its acquisition sights will be good investment targets.
I am positive we will have more “signals” in the very near future.
Source: Pfizer shouts its message to the world
Andrew, insightful article into Signaling Theory and it's relationship to investing. Consumers rely on these signals because talk is cheap. We need more than words.
I have written extensively on signaling and believe there are just six "currencies" companies risk or spend to send honest and reliable messages – whether they're conscious of it or not. And customers weigh these "investments" in their minds as they analyze buying decisions.
With Pfizer’s CEO risking reputation and prestige to tell the world he's willing to buy his rivals. Might his own job be on the line?