Is China’s GDP One Big Lie?
Posted on: Feb 9th, 2009 | By Irwin Greenstein | Filed under Emerging Markets
Investors often look to a country’s GDP to determine whether or not invest in its markets, but when it comes to China the official rate of growth could be exaggerated based on a new, revealing data.
A little-known indicator surfaced as China was preparing to attend the first meeting of the Committee on Statistics under the United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific, held in Bangkok, Thailand, from February 4-6.
An article in the People’s Daily called into question the final official GDP numbers for 2008 issued by China’s National Bureau of Statistics. Apparently, the 6.8% positive growth released in Q4 2008 did not correlate with the negative growth in China’s power consumption.
Now it seems that China will face a power glut this year, further calling into question its official GDP data.
The China Electricity Council (CEC) on Wednesday said in a report that demand for energy is expected to decline this year – with a possible uptick starting in Q3. The report cites shrinking exports as the culprit.
We’ve already written extensively about China’s record unemployment and factory closures. However, the extent of the problems have rarely become as clear as with the current CEC report on lower power consumption.
The CEC said that power usage grew 5.23% in 2008, or 9.57% lower than a year ago and the slowest in eight years.
The shrinking demand was mainly attributed to the industrial sector. Approximately 3.43 trillion kilowatt-hours of electricity was used by the industry last year, up 3.83% from a year earlier, slower than the overall social power consumption growth rate for the first time.
In 2008, China’s economy has reached its slowest pace in seven years. Beijing reported that the year-on-year growth rate for the fourth quarter slid to 6.8% from 9% in Q3 and grew 9.9% for the first three quarters.
The big question now is: are those numbers reliable?
We’ve been advising investor for months now to avoid China and instead look at emerging economies in South and Southeast Asia. This latest revelation about China’s questionable GDP data underscores our ongoing concern about any near-term recovery in China.