The First Indicator that Predicted this Sub-prime Crisis is Flashing Red Again
Apr 23rd, 2008 | By Eric Roseman | Category: Politics & EconomicsBack in 2006, most U.S. stocks were still hitting new all-time highs and credit markets were soaring on the heels of ultra-low borrowing costs. But at the time, one important leading indicator was still flashing red.
Nine months later, that same indicator correctly predicted a U.S. economic slowdown that morphed into the sub-prime mortgage monster by July 2007. What was the indicator? Bond yield inversion.
Historically, bond-yield inversion is an anomaly associated with an impending recession in the major industrialized economies. It occurs when short-term government bond yields trade higher than long-term interest rates. That usually suggests an economic recession or slowdown lies ahead.
More often than not, this indicator has accurately forecasted a U.S. recession in the post WW II period. And this indicator was right on the money predicting a bear market in U.S. stocks and credit starting last July.
What an Inverted Bond Yield Looks Like…

Starting in September 2006 until March 2007, benchmark two-year U.S. Treasury bonds started to yield more than respective 10-year Treasury bonds. That’s a classic inverted yield curve where short rates yield more than longer term rates.
At the time, no one seemed to be concerned about it (except me). In fact, many pundits on Wall Street dismissed this bond anomaly as a short-term phenomenon. They said this it was driven mainly by foreigners buying up quality short-term U.S. Treasury paper and thereby reducing the available supply in the marketplace. But they were wrong.
The Father of Yield-Curve Inversion
Professor Campbell Harvey of Duke University was one of the first to point out the relationship between yield inversion and economic recession. He published his dissertation in 1988 in the Journal of Financial Economics. In 1989, he published a follow up article in the Financial Analysts Journal.
Harvey’s prediction about the usefulness of the yield-curve was right on target. In 1991, after the 1990 recession, he noted that inversions of the yield-curve have preceded the last five U.S. recessions. That suggests the curve can accurately forecast the turning points of the business cycle.
Indeed, the yield-curve turned negative or inverted in late 2006 and successfully predicted the current U.S. economic slowdown. In some respects, the current slowdown has ballooned into the worst credit crisis since the Great Depression. I say that because not one, but several segments of the mortgage-backed market and other synthetic derivatives have clogged the financial system since last July.
Eight Countries Approaching or in
Actual Yield-Inversion
It’s true that no in-depth analysis or research has been conducted on the universality of yield-curve inversion abroad. But recent evidence suggests that once it hits the United States – the world’s largest credit market – it does spread to other industrialized economies.
As of mid-April, eight foreign markets are currently dogged by yield-curve inversion or approaching yield inversion.
Last year, the United Kingdom became the first G-7 economy after the United States to suffer yield-curve inversion for the better part of the year until last fall. For the record, the U.K. is now slowing sharply in 2008. Several British banks have come under pressure, one mortgage bank has failed and the housing market is unraveling.
Currently, six industrialized markets are mired in yield-curve inversion. These include Australia, New Zealand, Austria, Norway, Portugal and Switzerland. Two other markets now sport the same interest rates along the short and long end of the yield curve, including Denmark and Italy. This strongly suggests that an increasing number of mature economies are gradually being infected by America’s sub-prime slowdown as interest rates narrow.
Historically, the Anglo-Saxon economies have typically followed similar economic cycles. Expansions or contractions in economic activity have been simultaneous events that happen within months of each another.
This was the case in 1989-1990 when the United States suffered a recession and the United Kingdom, Australia and New Zealand soon followed suit. In the early 1980s, all three countries suffered the same economic hardships as the United States following a period of surging interest rates and inflation in the late 1970s. The same was true for most developed economies.
Decoupling or Re-coupling?
In the late 2000s, analysts have been quick to surmise that emerging markets and other economies in Europe have finally decoupled from the U.S. economic cycle. Although the emerging markets have shown incredible resilience since last July when sub-prime first bombed credit markets, other major or mature economies have not been as fortunate.
It looks like the United Kingdom is heading into a recession or a severe slowdown. The country’s credit markets have been bottled up for months, mortgages are turning sour and a leading mortgage bank collapsed last September (later rescued by The Bank of England).
British real estate is now contracting, especially in overheated London. The pound, though still relatively firm versus the beleaguered dollar, trades at an all-time low against the euro. The United Kingdom, in all likelihood, will join the United States and suffer a slowdown in 2008 or worse, a recession.
The majority of industrialized countries, including the European Union and Scandinavia, will increasingly share the same bond-yield inversion phenomenon that occurred in the United States 18 months ago. Over this period, benchmark 10-year Treasury yields have plummeted from 5.25% in late 2006 to 3.42% recently – a sizable gain for investors.
I expect yield-curve inversion and economic re-coupling to occur this year as the majority of mature economies suffer the same fate as the United States. Bond yields in Europe are poised to decline sharply despite the European Central Bank’s (ECB) adamant stand against inflation.
With more Eurozone bond markets inverting, it’s only a matter of time before central banks across the continent start hacking interest rates and the ECB abandons its inflation fight.
Bond-yield inversion is spreading. For European bond investors, this marks a good entry point to buy long-term government debt and investment-grade corporate paper ahead of a steeper yield curve by 2009 or 2010.
ERIC ROSEMAN, Investment Director
EDITOR’S NOTE: Bond yields continue to spread around the world. Mortgages are turning sour. But in the face of global crisis, a few well-placed opportunities are rising in the one asset class that even non-investors have to buy – whether they want to or not. Find out how to invest in this one asset class for a possible triple-digit gain this fall. Click here for details.
Advertisement
It's Official: We're In A Bear Market -- But The Next Big Profit Wave Is Taking Place RIGHT NOW!
A small group of ordinary individuals have discovered profits in a highly focused sub-niche of the currency market - that is literally driven by political and monetary uncertainty.
The following report outlines the exact details of how 487 BETA-testers had the opportunity to collect, on average, an extra $5,970 every 30 days following a simple 3-step formula.
Eric serves as an editor and Investment Director for The Sovereign Society's Commodity Trend Alert. Eric's talents include blending a dozen or more alternative investment funds to produce consistent returns to traditional asset classes and making commodity based recommendations with huge upside and limited downside.
